#11857337, By MrSensible Alien: Covenant

  • MrSensible 15 May 2017 12:50:50 26,517 posts
    Seen 1 day ago
    Registered 16 years ago
    simpleexplodingmaybe wrote:
    Aside from getting the movies funded I don't see why either Prometheus or David's experiments needed to be part of the Alien franchise at all.

    A story of Engineers, humans and the relationship between humans, androids and whatever comes next could easily have been its own totally independent new fictional universe.

    As plotholey as both the new films are a lot of that comes from trying to squeeze it into the established Alien canon. If it were possibly to switch off from that this prequel series would be a lot more narratively coherent
    Absolutely spot on. If this was a new franchise I think people would be a lot kinder to them as well - they'd certainly blow most other sci fi movies of recent years totally out of the water and be much more well received.
Sign in or register to reply